{ "selection": "Outcome-selected at user request: one of three models succeeds without skill and all three with revised skill. Illustrative example, not representative. First qualifying soup state2.", "caveats": [ "Original100calls/1500s vs revised180calls/2700s; effects combine skill and budget.", "Fable historical macOS GLFW vs revisedLinux OSMesa.", "Whole task native outcomes: {'control': {'n': 15, 'native_successes': 3}, 'candidate': {'n': 15, 'native_successes': 14}}" ], "chapters": [ { "title": "Alphabet soup into basket: 1/3 to 3/3", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "episodes": [ { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "condition": "plan-no-skill", "phase": "original", "batch": "fixed-budget", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "gpt-6-astra-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": false, "stop": "max_decisions", "wall_s": 1312.701898116, "model_wait_s": 1047.4139143409902, "sim_s": 77.7500000000002, "provider_calls": 100, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 346096, "output_tokens": 23990, "trace": "gpt-6-astra-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261014T055722Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261014T055727Z_0e92f856", "video": "gpt-6-astra-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261014T055722Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261014T055727Z_0e92f856/video.mp4", "host": null, "cost_usd": 5.4942, "usage_calls": 100, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 346096, "usage_output_tokens": 23990, "cache_read_tokens": 0, "cache_write_tokens": 333496, "video_sha256": "e42cedd458ab31c5cf107f2e504b73b0257b1b2c52c5d2dba38118c15b10f934", "source_job_id": "gpt-6-astra-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002" }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon", "condition": "plan-no-skill", "phase": "original", "batch": "fixed-budget", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "gemini-4-argon-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": true, "stop": "task_success", "wall_s": 653.6934331140001, "model_wait_s": 563.7817988220013, "sim_s": 24.449999999997328, "provider_calls": 55, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 307840, "output_tokens": 14674, "trace": "gemini-4-argon-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261014T055842Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261014T055847Z_54cb6e4b", "video": "gemini-4-argon-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261014T055842Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261014T055847Z_54cb6e4b/video.mp4", "host": null, "cost_usd": 0.7624199999999998, "usage_calls": 55, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 307840, "usage_output_tokens": 14674, "cache_read_tokens": 0, "cache_write_tokens": 0, "video_sha256": "1b90e119a7c8b83e32b5001e355bd9e7328aa94fe75b15503166e84a8b3619a9", "source_job_id": "gemini-4-argon-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002" }, { "model": "fable-5-1", "condition": "plan-no-skill", "phase": "original", "batch": "fixed-budget", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "fable-5-1-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": false, "stop": "max_consecutive_failures", "wall_s": 710.0545393750072, "model_wait_s": 699.0773485830869, "sim_s": 20.699999999999406, "provider_calls": 40, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 218344, "output_tokens": 50954, "trace": "fable-5-1-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261009T081623Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261009T081627Z_2b169462", "video": "fable-5-1-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261009T081623Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261009T081627Z_2b169462/video.mp4", "host": null, "cost_usd": 4.73114, "usage_calls": 40, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 218344, "usage_output_tokens": 50954, "cache_read_tokens": 0, "cache_write_tokens": 0, "video_sha256": "44cb6514dfbbd9b1b3aa9c30a3e7f3e3ff597aba25a621048f3545f6a8b0fb07", "source_job_id": "fable-5-1-medium-plan-rationale-memory--libero_object-00--state-002" }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "condition": "candidate", "phase": "confirmation", "batch": "confirm-round2-standard", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "gpt-6-astra-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": true, "stop": "task_success", "wall_s": 267.01807516499866, "model_wait_s": 220.34268640000118, "sim_s": 12.750000000000927, "provider_calls": 38, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 150958, "output_tokens": 6294, "trace": "gpt-6-astra-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202655Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202700Z_bb43e8e1", "video": "gpt-6-astra-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202655Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202700Z_bb43e8e1/video.mp4", "host": "ruling-amber-guineafowl", "cost_usd": 1.5104, "usage_calls": 38, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 150958, "usage_output_tokens": 6294, "cache_read_tokens": 59070, "cache_write_tokens": 87100, "video_sha256": "04c27eb8264bffd78c3024a1c5a01c2b907fdc60fb7eeefaddba8efc2c6ff947", "source_job_id": "gpt-6-astra-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002" }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon", "condition": "candidate", "phase": "confirmation", "batch": "confirm-round2-standard", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "gemini-4-argon-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": true, "stop": "task_success", "wall_s": 415.77451003200076, "model_wait_s": 366.8543576760003, "sim_s": 13.550000000001194, "provider_calls": 36, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 220578, "output_tokens": 8885, "trace": "gemini-4-argon-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202656Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202701Z_1d576053", "video": "gemini-4-argon-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202656Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202701Z_1d576053/video.mp4", "host": "ruling-amber-guineafowl", "cost_usd": 0.530006, "usage_calls": 36, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 220578, "usage_output_tokens": 8885, "cache_read_tokens": 0, "cache_write_tokens": 0, "video_sha256": "5053b90ff541e946aa3e1589bce24177f52a6632624fdb48bfd62236f40bd1c1", "source_job_id": "gemini-4-argon-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002" }, { "model": "fable-5-1", "condition": "candidate", "phase": "confirmation", "batch": "confirm-round2-standard", "suite": "libero_object", "task_id": 0, "state": 2, "job_id": "fable-5-1-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002", "finished": true, "native_success": true, "stop": "task_success", "wall_s": 1032.883678364, "model_wait_s": 949.6179952919956, "sim_s": 23.499999999997854, "provider_calls": 64, "provider_errors": 0, "input_tokens": 441630, "output_tokens": 66311, "trace": "fable-5-1-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202505Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202510Z_b7af9f8d", "video": "fable-5-1-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002/episode-20261015T202505Z/traces/libero_libero_object_pick_up_the_alphabet_soup_and_place_it_in_the_basket/20261015T202510Z_b7af9f8d/video.mp4", "host": "ruling-amber-guineafowl", "cost_usd": 7.7318500000000006, "usage_calls": 64, "unpriced_calls": 0, "usage_input_tokens": 441630, "usage_output_tokens": 66311, "cache_read_tokens": 0, "cache_write_tokens": 0, "video_sha256": "8aaf8a45a2f9f37c3c94fbecdfe1ba11a32094b53fc19ab2d169cacd202ecaff", "source_job_id": "fable-5-1-medium-candidate--libero_object-00--state-002" } ], "render_duration_s": 80 } ], "whole_cohort": { "control": { "n": 15, "native_successes": 3 }, "candidate": { "n": 15, "native_successes": 14 } }, "playback_speed": 1, "time_basis": "Simulation replay. API waiting omitted; actual episode wall time shown per panel.", "condition": "Revised task skill versus historical no-task-skill planning; outcome-selected illustrative example." }